Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Book Bans, Disinformation, and Cultural Erasure: The Censorship Movement in Libraries, Schools, and Society - by Paul Jaeger

As someone with research interests in both book banning and "fake news" (disinformation) this book, which demonstrates how they intersect as a means of expunging references to marginalized people, is particularly insightful. While I did not agree with everything Jaegar said, all of it was thought provoking.

Jaeger provides historical perspective to demonstrate that combining disinformation with censorship is not a new tactic. Examples he provides have the same ring to much of the disinformation we hear around censorship today.

I am not sure if Jaegar coined the term "polycrisis" to describe the collective mess we are all experiencing but his definition could not have been more on point.

Even if you have never heard the term polycrisis before reading this book, it seems that being alive in the twenty-first century gives you a pretty good understanding of its meaning without this book belaboring it.

The Comstock Act, named for Anthony Comstock, ostensibly was created to prevent indecent materials from being sent through the US postal service, but in the late nineteenth century Comstock used it to prevent not only information about birth control from being mailed, but virtually any medical information pertaining to women's health and women's bodies. He targeted women health practitioners and authors. Among those he "hounded" into suicide was Ira Craddock

Craddock was to be imprisoned for her book The Wedding Night, which the judge and jury were not allowed to read; Comstock had not read the book either because he could tell, based on the title, that the book clearly violated the law.

 Founder of Planned Parenthood Margaret Sanger was arrested for writing and distributing a pamphlet on birth control, which Comstock also succeeded in having banned without reading it.

In 1928 Democratic Presidential candidate Al Smith was derailed by a disinformation campaign by the Ku Klux Klan which had a posse of radio preachers helping them spread falsehoods to prevent Smith from becoming president "If he is chosen...you will not be allowed to read or have a bible" read one note sent home with every child enrolled in the Daytona Beach Florida school system.

We can see some of these same tactics being used today to vilify the LGBTQIA+ population, as well as other marginalized groups.

An especially interesting point Jaeger makes is that most of the banned authors are women.

The gender of the author seems to be a factor that further antagonizes those seeking to censor books. The fact that librarianship is a profession overwhelmingly comprised of women seems also to be encouraging the attacks on the profession. By heavily focusing on women authors and women librarians, the bans simultaneously erase BIPOC and LGBTQIA+ voices and reinforce traditional gender hierarchies in which the perspective of man is of much greater importance. 

Destruction of libraries as a means of cultural erasure has a long history. From the Roman empire to the Spanish conquistadores, to Nazi book burnings, and other assaults, invaders have found ways to annihilate the intellectual and artistic works of those they conquered.

Proactive and self censorship involving libraries removing materials that may be prohibited and authors only writing what they believe will pass the censors is evident today, as it was in Joseph Statin's Soviet Union.

As much as Jaeger is against book bans, he points out several times that the librarians in Jamestown, Michigan perhaps should have caved to demands to remove Maia Kobabe's Gender Queer. The residents voted to defund the library over the librarians' refusal to ban the book. He suggests that the library would be still be open and the librarians still employed it they had removed the book. I disagree with Jaeger. It is never about one book. I expect that the next request would have been for removal of some entire category of "inappropriate" material, as is the trend.

The work could have done with some more careful editing. It was, nevertheless, a good, thoughtful read.

Tuesday, October 27, 2026

Lords of Serendipity - by Randy Boyagoda

University satire just gets darker and darker, even as it shines a brighter light on the inner workings of the Academy.

Boyagoda's work has readers traveling from Sri Lanka, to Italy, to the United States exploring how the Ivory Tower covers up things it doesn't like and maintains the privilege of the white, male hierarchy, all while presenting a face that wears a DEI mask. My professor husband and I listened to this on Audible and enjoyed some true belly laughs together.

There were a lot of characters in this novel, of course my favorite was Patricia, the information literacy librarian at the fictitious Haven College. Always fighting the good fight, she was a true educator, but without the protection of tenure. She is forced into early retirement by "Puck" an AI assistant she is required to "train". 

I must admit that I am happy to have decided for myself to retire early. The Administration at my University would like nothing more than to have AI do all the librarians' jobs, and shrink the physical space of the library as well. Currently the number of professional librarians is smaller by three than when I first started, and the building space is smaller by one entire floor. Plans are to make it smaller still within the next few years. Encroachment was an issue for the entire 27 years I worked there. Who needs a library anyway? No one reads books anymore. 

Friday, October 9, 2026

The Banned Books Club - by Brenda Novak

When Gia Rossi returns to her hometown to help her dying mother she expected to have to confront the hostile neighbors who think she ruined the life of Mr. Hart, the teacher who molested her seventeen years prior. She did not expect her sister to disappear with Gia's two young nephews and to navigate her brother-in-law's hostility.

Of course I could hardly resist reading this one for Banned Books Week, although it wasn’t really what I expected.

There was in fact only a little of the story that involved book banning. While some action takes place around a reunion of a high school banned books club (a club that was started as a rebellion against the PTA who insisted on removing The Catcher in the Rye, The Outsiders, and The Handmaid's Tale from Honors English) with a bit of editing the same story could have been written about an ecology club, a drama troupe, the Gay Straight Alliance, the Student Government Organization, or any other high school group. Likewise, there aren't any heroes who vanquished book banning villains.

The Banned Books Club is still meeting after seventeen years and are reading Stephen King's Cujo. One member suggests that she understands why some people would want to ban it, as it was "upsetting" and furthermore had no "message". Gia points out that horror novels are simply meant to entertain, and don't necessarily need a message. This might have been my favorite line in the book. I think that too often book publishers, especially for children's and Young Adult books, seem bent on everything having a moral. We also need silly stories that simply entertain, and make reading fun. Reading fun books is how people learn to love reading.

I ordered a signed copy of this book from the author’s website. It came with a little puzzle in a test-tube shaped container 

.




Thursday, October 8, 2026

Suggested Reading - by Dave Connis

Clara Evans is without a doubt a rather bookish person. She not only runs a book club and several Tiny Little Libraries, she also volunteers at the Lupton Academy school library. And when she learns that over fifty books have been banned from her private high school she creates a secret "locker library" (a la Ban This Book) to ensure that her classmates still have access to the "prohibited media", although they (the students) haven't even been notified that the books have been removed. As a private school Lupton Academy can do what it likes without input from the community.

One of Clara's new favorite books, Don't Tread on Me, is among the prohibited media. DTOM is about a clandestine library which makes this whole story somewhat meta. 

Clara's character is well developed. We find her questioning her own motives for creating the locker library, as well she begins to wonder whether perhaps some books should be banned. She notes that Catcher in the Rye may have incited Mark David Chapman to murder John Lennon, and driven one of her friends to consider suicide. Her self-questioning ultimately allows her to think more deeply about the book bans, and hone her arguments against the censorship. That's how critical thinking works. When we get exposed to new ideas we may struggle with the new information and, whether we change our minds or not, we have a better understanding of the issues and can make our own well-reasoned arguments.

Although Don't Tread on Me is a fictitious book there are quite a few real books named in Suggested Reading. All have been banned or challenged somewhere, sometime. Links in the following list are to my reviews on this blog. This list is more or less in the order the books are named in Suggested Reading.

Fahrenheit 451 by Ray Bradbury

Hunger Games by Suzanne Collins

Where the Wild Things Are by Maurice Sendak

The Very Hungry Caterpillar by Eric Carle

Their Eyes Were Watching God by Zora Neale Hurston

A Wrinkle in Time by Madeleine L'Engle

I Know Why the Caged Bird Sings by Maya Angelou

Speak by Laurie Halse Anderson

The Perks of Being a Wallflower by Stephen Chbosky

Animal Farm by George Orwell

The Anarchist Cookbook by William Powell

The Chocolate War by Robert Cormier

Two Boys Kissing by David Levithan

Catcher in the Rye by J.D. Salinger

Neverwhere by Neil Gaiman

Bridge to Terabithia by Katherine Paterson

The Grapes of Wrath by John Steinbeck

The Adventures of Captain Underpants by Dav Pilkey

One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest by Ken Kesey

Roll of Thunder, Hear My Cry by Mildred D. Taylor

To Kill a Mockingbird by Harper Lee


Two Book Series were referenced without actually being named:

Harry Potter by J.K. Rowling

A Series of Unfortunate Events by Lemony Snicker

Wednesday, October 7, 2026

Occulted - by Amy Rose, Ryan Estrada, Jeongmin Lee

One of Amy Rose's early memories is of seeing Comet Hale-Bopp streak through the sky in 1997. The next day she learned of the mass suicide of members of the Heaven's Gate cult. It was when she began to realize that perhaps the temple she lived in with her mother was part of a cult as well.

One of the ways the cult's leader ("They") controlled their followers was by limiting information. They had a library, but did not allow others to access it. Amy sometimes snuck in to read. It was in They's library that Amy learned what a cult was and how the leaders were able to manipulate people into following them. They disliked Amy and had her sent to live with another family outside of the temple. Jeanie and Derek were not part of They's cult and made sure Amy got to go to the library regularly where she could pick out whatever books she wanted. 

Occulted: "An astronomical term for when something is concealed from view"

The title of the book is layered in meaning. The definition provided above is from the last page of the book. Rose points out that "the temple tried to conceal so much of the beauty of the world with control and fear. They told us the only way to grow was to stay hidden."

Book banners also seem to believe that by hiding information they are somehow facilitating growth. Concerns from the left and the right about book content use the same language. Suggesting that certain books are "harmful" or "problematic". As Ira Wells points out in his book On Book Banning 

Book banning harms some children by depriving them of information or narratives that may have enriched their lives. It harms other by whitewashing or severing them from history and presenting a sanitized version of reality. It impairs their development as democratic citizens, teaching them that when confronted with a disagreeable or upsetting viewpoint, the solution is to ban, silence, or prohibit.

Rose was indeed harmed by not having access to books and information. Going to the library was her salvation.

Tuesday, October 6, 2026

Americus - by MK Reed & Jonathan Hill

In the fictional town of Americus, Oklahoma some parents are in an uproar over the availability of the popular book series The Chronicles of Apathea Ravenchilde, the Huntress Witch in the public library. A group from "Keep Faith in Christ" descends upon a local library board meeting and demands that the books be banned over concerns about devil worship and witchcraft. Claiming that the books are "scientifically proven to be harmful to children" they insist that they are "damning their immortal souls. Board members counter that the library, as a government institution "cannot legally discriminate based on religious objections". Next, cue the parent arguing that the books are also obscene and the recitation of an out-of-context passage - that is most definitely not obscene. Calling books pornographic or obscene is a common tactic among those who would ban books. This post from EveryLibrary provides more context on this.

Of course many of the protesters haven't even read the books and are simply following their tribe.

Scowling faces are rampant in the illustrations of this graphic novel (of both of the book banners and defenders of free expression). However, the characters, despite some cliched tropes, do have some depth.

Monday, October 5, 2026

On Book Banning - by Ira Wells

Whenever I talk about book banning I make clear that the current crisis is driven by the religious right who are requesting the removal of thousands of books from schools and libraries (and have lately taken to targeting booksellers as well). I also make clear that they are not the only ones who are looking to censor what we can read. Book challenges come from both the left and the right, feminists and misogynists, people of a variety of religious backgrounds, politicians, and even from librarians. Ira Wells recognizes this and does not shy away from discussing this full range of restrictions and its consequences.

Wells begins by describing a "library audit" conducted at his children's (Ontario, Canada) elementary school. 

...the principal...told a group of parents...that she wished she could get rid of "all the old books". The bulk of the library's holdings were, from her perspective, to Eurocentric, too male, too heteronormative.

By "old books" the principal meant any book over 15 years old, regardless of its other qualities. This would necessarily include a lot of children's classic works, as well as plenty of works by LGBTQ authors and BIPOC authors.

He makes fair comparison between the Mom's for Liberty crowd in Florida and the Ontario progressives each with their own agenda for "child safety". Each group has identified categories of books that they believe should go. While the religious right wants all books with LGBTQ themes removed, the Canadian progressives would like to see books that are not "woke" enough removed.

Greater sensitivity to racially charged language and imagery has resulted in school library challenges to The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn, Of Mice and Men, and several titles by Dr. Seuss. After some school districts banned from classrooms all books by non-Black authors that contain the N-word, novels like Lord of the Flies and To Kill a Mockingbird went from being mandatory to unteachable.

Predictably both groups of would be banners identify the works they'd like removed as "potential sources of student 'harm'". 

Also, predictably, the principal of Wells' children's school insisted that she was not banning any books, but rather simply "weeding" the collection.

...but this is a misrepresentation of library protocol: As the American Library Association states, "While weeding is essential to the collection development process, it should not be used as a deselection tool for controversial materials."  

Wells work also explores the history of book banning through a lens of religion as well as the history of libraries and the freedom of speech, current trends in monitoring speech including "soft censorship" which happens when titles are excluded from publication or purchase in order to avoid challenges.