As someone with research interests in both book banning and "fake news" (disinformation) this book, which demonstrates how they intersect as a means of expunging references to marginalized people, is particularly insightful. While I did not agree with everything Jaegar said, all of it was thought provoking.
Jaeger provides historical perspective to demonstrate that combining disinformation with censorship is not a new tactic. Examples he provides have the same ring to much of the disinformation we hear around censorship today.
I am not sure if Jaegar coined the term "polycrisis" to describe the collective mess we are all experiencing but his definition could not have been more on point.
Even if you have never heard the term polycrisis before reading this book, it seems that being alive in the twenty-first century gives you a pretty good understanding of its meaning without this book belaboring it.
The Comstock Act, named for Anthony Comstock, ostensibly was created to prevent indecent materials from being sent through the US postal service, but in the late nineteenth century Comstock used it to prevent not only information about birth control from being mailed, but virtually any medical information pertaining to women's health and women's bodies. He targeted women health practitioners and authors. Among those he "hounded" into suicide was Ira Craddock
Craddock was to be imprisoned for her book The Wedding Night, which the judge and jury were not allowed to read; Comstock had not read the book either because he could tell, based on the title, that the book clearly violated the law.
Founder of Planned Parenthood Margaret Sanger was arrested for writing and distributing a pamphlet on birth control, which Comstock also succeeded in having banned without reading it.
In 1928 Democratic Presidential candidate Al Smith was derailed by a disinformation campaign by the Ku Klux Klan which had a posse of radio preachers helping them spread falsehoods to prevent Smith from becoming president "If he is chosen...you will not be allowed to read or have a bible" read one note sent home with every child enrolled in the Daytona Beach Florida school system.
We can see some of these same tactics being used today to vilify the LGBTQIA+ population, as well as other marginalized groups.
An especially interesting point Jaeger makes is that most of the banned authors are women.
The gender of the author seems to be a factor that further antagonizes those seeking to censor books. The fact that librarianship is a profession overwhelmingly comprised of women seems also to be encouraging the attacks on the profession. By heavily focusing on women authors and women librarians, the bans simultaneously erase BIPOC and LGBTQIA+ voices and reinforce traditional gender hierarchies in which the perspective of man is of much greater importance.
Destruction of libraries as a means of cultural erasure has a long history. From the Roman empire to the Spanish conquistadores, to Nazi book burnings, and other assaults, invaders have found ways to annihilate the intellectual and artistic works of those they conquered.
Proactive and self censorship involving libraries removing materials that may be prohibited and authors only writing what they believe will pass the censors is evident today, as it was in Joseph Statin's Soviet Union.
As much as Jaeger is against book bans, he points out several times that the librarians in Jamestown, Michigan perhaps should have caved to demands to remove Maia Kobabe's Gender Queer. The residents voted to defund the library over the librarians' refusal to ban the book. He suggests that the library would be still be open and the librarians still employed it they had removed the book. I disagree with Jaeger. It is never about one book. I expect that the next request would have been for removal of some entire category of "inappropriate" material, as is the trend.
The work could have done with some more careful editing. It was, nevertheless, a good, thoughtful read.
No comments:
Post a Comment